“F” grew up in southern California and learned Spanish as
her first language. She learned
English by watching children's cartoons on TV and through her siblings. Her parent’s are first
generation immigrants and do not speak English very well. “F” says that her parents didn't show
interest in teaching her English as a language. Her parents value traditions and customs and
feared her losing them by speaking English. I asked "F" if she experienced any discrimination in school but for the most part she hadn't, the schools she attended always had a large Hispanic population. However "F" felt intimidated by the white kids in her school
because they seemed smarter and more successful. While “F” has many American English
speaking friends she told me she always has felt more comfortable around
Spanish speakers no matter where they are from. "F" says Spanish speakers can relate to each other off the back because
of their cultural similarities. In this sense "F" saw the power of language as a unifier that connected her together with Spanish speakers here in the United States. She also felt that her Spanish speaking skills were subordinate to English speakers, which can lead to a disconnection between two groups.
“M” is a Mexican-American but she
returned to Mexico at the age of 7.
Her parents had gotten involved with child protective services and they
were worried their children would be put into the foster care system, so they all
packed up for Jalisco, Mexico.
When “M” returned to school in Jalisco it was obvious to everyone that
she was American, and they gave her the nickname gringa. While Spanish was her first language she had an obvious American accent and that created tensions between
her and the classmates in school.
After sometime she lost her “gringa” accent and soon after lost all her
knowledge of the English language. In order to pursue a higher education “M” left
her family at the age of 16 to return back to LA and live with an uncle. When she returned to school in LA she knew
absolutely no English. “M” told me she felt hopeful because there was a large Spanish speaking
Hispanic population at school. Her hopes were false, the Mexican-American
students labeled her as a “Chunt” and would not speak to her, or offer any
help. “M” tells me that these
students made huge efforts to become American, and didn’t want to ruin their
reputations by speaking to her.
For “M” language separated her from her peers, even when it was the same
language. Perhaps similar to the
El Salvadorian entering a Mexican workforce, the students felt that they had
worked hard to feel comfortable here, so they wanted “M” to work hard in the
same way.
“J” was my only interviewee that did not speak Spanish as a first language. “J”
is a Mexican-American with Spanish speaking parents who also grew up in the LA
area. “J” said that not knowing
Spanish was a negative impact on his personal identity. He dealt with a lot of taunting from
other Spanish speaking students in high school who labeled him as a guerro or
gringo because he did not speak Spanish, even though he looked just as
Mexican-American as the other students. He told me, “There were even times I
was told I wasn’t a “real” Mexican or Latino because I didn’t speak Spanish.” During high school “J” felt
disconnected with his heritage, but now in college taking Spanish classes has
helped him feel more connected. For "J" language was something that separated him from his peers, however after taking classes and learning Spanish he feels more connected. Language and culture are so closely related that sometimes, as is for the case of "J", without the language of your past you cannot fully understand the culture that surrounds it.
I like the range of your interview subjects. M's story is amazing, having to completely flip-flop between languages at such a young age. The whole concept in your cases of what a "real" Mexican/Latino is fascinates me. My roommate has a similar background to J, and he's expressed confusion and frustration at people who take pride in being "real" Mexicans. There are so many cultural, ethnic and religious
ReplyDeletefactors involved, and I think the specific definitions people give terms like "Mexican" and "Latino" are unrealistic.
There are a couple spelling and punctuation errors that could be fixed before the final submission, but the writing and stories are otherwise sound.
I like the idea of your statement that “F” saw the language as a unifier to connect her to other Spanish speakers in the U.S. This is a very powerful statement.
ReplyDeleteIn the case of “M”, it is very interesting that because she had lived in the U.S., she was now looked at as a ‘gringa’ to her classmates. It’s a very interesting turn of events how she was pushed away at first because of her ‘gringa’ accent was discriminated against when she moved back to L.A. because she couldn’t speak English
Contrary to what “F” had expressed, it seems that “M” views language as a mechanism of segregation.
And “J” was discriminated against because he couldn’t speak Spanish, even though he lived in L.A. because it disconnected him from his heritage.
I really enjoyed reading your blog and discovering the views of your three interviewees. It is so interesting how three people can have such different experiences regarding language. Very well put together, just a few grammatical mistakes; ‘Loosing’… should be ‘losing’, ‘Is’… should be ‘if’.